UPDATE: I just looked into the 7 Series vs the Trilogy 40 in more detail here and came to a slightly different conclusion.
Tom Konrad CFA
|Geothermal heat pump diagram via Bigstock|
Waterfurnace Renewable Energy (TSX:WFI, OTC:WFIFF) launched its new highly efficient 7 Series geothermal heat pumps (GHP) today. The 7 Series commercial release beats Climatemaster’s (a division of LSB Industries (NYSE:LXU)) Trilogy 40 as the first commercially available GHP with a variable speed compressor. The Trilogy 40 is currently available as part of a pilot program, and is expected to be commercially available later this year. The variable speed compressor enables a significant jump in efficiency over previous two-stage compressors.
I looked at the technology behind these new heat pumps in the article Geothermal Heat Pumps: The Next Generation in May, soon after Climatemaster introduced the Trilogy. At the time, we only knew that Waterfurnace expected the 7 Series to be “more efficient” than the Trilogy. Now we have detailed specs, I thought I’d compare them head-to-head:
As you can see from the chart above, Waterfurnace managed to nudge out Climatemaster in both cooling (EER) and heating (COP) efficiency ratings. Both are on linear scales, so the Series 7 is 2.5% more efficient at cooling and 6% more efficient for heating than the Trilogy. With top efficiency ratings, the Waterfurnace GHP will likely appeal to customers who must have “the best” of everything.
The efficiency of the GHP unit is only one factor in overall system efficiency, and efficiency is only one factor in the decision of what to install. Price will be an important factor as well, although given the likelihood that these variable speed GHPs will be priced at a significant premium, price sensitive customers will most likely install two-stage GHPs. Waterfurnace’s Series 5 was launched in March, at a slightly lower price than the previous Envison product it replaced, while maintaining all the features and efficiency of that model.
The most important factor for installers will be dealer support and ease of install, especially for the residential market. Both Climatemaster and Waterfurnace seem to have simplified installation with the new models, while dealer support is much more a local issue, and is determined by the installer’s relationship with their distributor.
Along with the Series 7, Waterfurnace is introducing a new “IntelliZone2″ zone controller, which will simplify the installation and use of their Series 5 and 7 products with multiple zones. On the other hand, Climatemaster’s Trilogy includes a propriatary “Q-mode” which allows the heat pump to create hot water year round. Most rival heat pumps only create hot water when being used to heat or cool the building. In new residential applications without an existing water heater, Q-mode could easily give Trilogy the edge over the 7 Series, since it would allow the contractor to dispense with a secondary hot water source.
Neither of these two GHPs is the clear winner, with the 7 Series’ edge in efficiency countered by the year-round hot water of the Trilogy’s Q-Mode. Waterfurnace’s efficiency edge is more significant in heating-dominated climates, such as the Northern US and Canada, while Climatemaster’s Q-Mode will probably give the Trilogy an edge in new-build markets. Existing relationships between installers and their dritributers will probably dominate both in many cases. UPDATE: The Series 7′s earlier commercial availability will make Waterfurnace’s offering the only real choice for installations over the next few months.
The biggest winners will be consumers, who now have both cheaper versions of two-stage GHP technology available, as well as the option to enter a whole new frontier of HVAC energy efficiency.
Disclosure: Long LXU, WFIFF
This article was first published on the author’s Forbes.com blog, Green Stocks.
DISCLAIMER: Past performance is not a guarantee or a reliable indicator of future results. This article contains the current opinions of the author and such opinions are subject to change without notice. This article has been distributed for informational purposes only. Forecasts, estimates, and certain information contained herein should not be considered as investment advice or a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or investment product. Information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but not guaranteed.